C2020-612 A00-260 642-998 BH0-013 70-687 646-562 070-466 EX0-102 70-515 C4090-958 C4090-958 MB2-701 70-642 VCPD510 1Z0-418 640-911 FCNSP.v5 MB6-889 642-874 642-742 1Z0-053 070-413 OG0-091 PMI-100 C2180-272 70-480 070-346 070-480 3203 HP2-B110 HP0-M44 P2080-034 HP0-J73 CPA 70-484 70-462 070-414 N10-005 642-997 TT0-101 300-135 220-801 3202 1Y0-370 E20-390 70-461 SY0-401 1Z0-508 NS0-156 70-640 1D0-520 70-532 MB2-703 C_TADM51_731 CISSP-ISSMP C2020-632 NS0-101 G2700 MB7-700 VCAD510 70-243 70-465 74-343 MB5-705 200-120 VCAP5-DCD MB2-702 70-412 NS0-145 P2090-038 ICBB GSNA 700-505 1Z0-899 LOT-802 642-832 201-01 JN0-360 PMI-001 1Z0-060 PMI-SP 70-414 70-467 1Z0-146 1Z0-533 C2040-405 70-483 70-464 250-315 070-467 1Z0-599 M70-101 P2180-031 640-722 C2080-474 3107 070-457 MB2-700 HP2-T23 C2010-501 ITIL MB7-701 648-244 700-501 MB6-872 EX300 1Z0-507 MB6-871 NS0-155 70-417 CV0-001 070-411 70-489 C_TADM51702 EX200 HP2-B115 C-TERP10-60 646-365 98-365 1Z0-497 070-463 70-410 70-498 1Z0-047 70-486 A00-280 OG0-093 070-347 CQE IIA-CFSA E20-517 EX0-001 1Y0-200 70-458 640-554 1Z0-102 C2180-275 70-346 MB7-702 JK0-019 070-410 1Z0-055 1Y0-A20 74-338 70-497 98-363 70-466 300-101 CCD-410 70-336 C2030-280 CBAP 117-101 PRINCE2 C2090-730 C_TSCM52_66 117-010 VCAW510 C4040-122 HP2-B120 98-367
House Bill 1237 – A Good Step for HOA Owners | Angela Williams :: For Colorado State Senator District 33

House Bill 1237 – A Good Step for HOA Owners

In his May 16, 2012, column, Stan Hrincevich bemoans the legislative process and the lack of enforcement mechanisms in the Colorado Common Interest Ownership Act (“CCIOA”), which governs homeowners associations. I agree with Mr. Hrincevich: the legislative process can be frustrating. That frustration is not limited to HOA legislation. Bills get amended in committee, voted down on the floor, and filibustered until time runs out in the session. We saw each of these things happen during the 2012 general session. Even so, the Colorado legislature managed to pass laws that benefit Coloradoans.

House Bill 12-1237—the HOA Records Bill—is one of those laws that specifically benefits homeowners living in community associations. The HOA Records Bill clarifies what constitutes a record of the association and what records associations must be produced to owners, creates a list of documents excluded from mandatory disclosure to owners, and removes the requirement that owners state a “proper purpose” for seeing the records they request.

As a legislator, I heard loud and clear from my constituents that the old laws concerning HOA records were confusing and contained too many hurdles for homeowners who wanted access to HOA documents. Among other things, HOAs failed to keep adequate records, or they refused to release records because they determined unilaterally that owners did not state proper purposes for their requests. The HOA Information Officer’s first annual report substantiated this concern—17% of complaints logged by the HOA Information Office during its initial year of operation related to transparency and records. The types of complaints also suggested that the existing statute did not lend itself to enforcement. The statute contained ambiguities that warranted clarification. A clearer statute could achieve more consistent application and greater compliance by HOAs.

In other words, the old HOA records statute did not suffer from an ineffective enforcement mechanism. Rather, the old statute was open to interpretation and, in some ways, invited abuses. Through HB 12-1237, I sought to correct the ambiguities in the statute and remove the sometimes inappropriately applied provisions that prevented owners from accessing information they should be entitled to receive. My co-sponsor, Senator Harvey, who represents constituents in Highlands Ranch (the biggest HOA in the state and one of the largest community associations in the country), recognized the clear benefits of HB 12-1237 too. Together we achieved unanimous committee and House and Senate approval, with the House concurring with Senate amendments on a 62 to 3 vote, during a highly contentious and partisan session. That’s no small victory for homeowners living in HOAs.

The HOA Records Bill is based on a uniform act created by content experts from across the United States. As in the uniform act, early versions of the HOA Records Bill excluded certain documents related to pending or threatened litigation, which, as Mr. Hrincevich notes, could serve as a broad catch-all for associations to refuse to produce records. That language was removed from the final version of the HOA Records Bill. Attorney work product, on the other hand, remains protected from disclosure. Just as Broncos fans cannot expect John Fox to publish his play book for the next big game, homeowners should not expect access to privileged and confidential documentation prepared by their association’s attorney when advising the board on legal matters or in preparation for litigation. This is only fair: an HOA board is not permitted to obtain attorney work product from the lawyer representing an owner against the HOA.

While I can agree with a concern about inadequate enforcement provisions in CCIOA, I cannot agree that improved enforcement mechanisms alone would solve problems arising from unclear statutes. Additionally, the jury is still out on what enforcement mechanisms CCIOA should include. House Bill 12-1237 was a necessary first step before going down the enforcement road. Unclear provisions of CCIOA, like the records provision, need to be clarified before associations can be penalized for failing to comply. As legislators, it is our duty to ensure that the laws in Colorado make sense, are balanced, and can reasonably be complied with. Our efforts relating to consumer protections and HOAs are just beginning. However, as with most things, we must proceed one step at a time.

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

buy Mens Canada Goose LODGE DOWN JACKET Order Womens Canada Goose MONTEBELLO Parka Discount Cheap Womens Canada Goose KENSINGTON Parka Buy Womens Canada Goose BROOKVALE HOODED COAT Black buy Mens Canada Goose HYBRIDGE LITE VEST Discount Womens Canada Goose CHELSEA Parka Discount Mens Canada Goose CHATEAU Parka Mens Canada Goose Macmillan Parka Mens Canada Goose Langford Parka buy Mens Canada Goose BROOKVALE HOODY Discount Mens Canada Goose BRACEBRIDGE JACKET Discount Authentic Womens Canada Goose MONCTON JACKET Discount Womens Canada Goose FREESTYLE VEST Buy Womens Canada Goose HYBRIDGE LITE COAT Pacific Blue Discount Womens Canada Goose CAMP COAT White Sale Online Womens Canada Goose MYSTIQUE Parka Mens Canada Goose RESOLUTE Parka Womens Canada Goose WHISTLER Parka Buy Mens Canada Goose LODGE HOODY Discount cheap sale Mens Canada Goose Selkirk Parka Authentic Womens Canada Goose MONCTON JACKET Buy Womens Canada Goose HYBRIDGE LITE COAT Black Mens Canada Goose COASTAL SHELL Pacific Blue Mid Grey top sale 2015 and 2016 Buy Womens Canada Goose HYBRIDGE LITE COAT Pacific Blue Discount Mens Canada Goose COASTAL SHELL Pacific Blue Mid Grey top sale 2015 and 2016 Authentic Womens Canada Goose COASTAL SHELL JACKET Discount Mens Canada Goose COASTAL SHELL Pacific Blue Mid Grey top sale 2015 and 2016 Discount Womens Canada Goose EXPEDITION Parka Authentic Womens Canada Goose BRACEBRIDGE JACKET Discount Womens Canada Goose EXPEDITION Parka Buy Womens Canada Goose BROOKVALE HOODED COAT Black buy Mens Canada Goose HYBRIDGE LITE VEST Womens Canada Goose VICTORIA Parka Mens Canada Goose TRENTON JACKET Discount Authentic Womens Canada Goose MONCTON JACKET Authentic Womens Canada Goose COASTAL SHELL JACKET